Late in the
afternoon this past Friday, four days before the election, the weekly “New York
Democrats In Action” email went out to the State Democratic Party list. In
large letters across the top was a reminder that polls would be open from 6
a.m. to 9 p.m. on Election Day.
But those wondering who they should be voting for when they head to those polls could be forgiven for being confused.
Only by scrolling to nearly the bottom of the
email, past updates about things like Gov. David Paterson’s swine flu
declarations and his World Series wager with Pennsylvania Gov. Ed Rendell, was
there a mention of the mayor’s race and an internal campaign poll showing
Democratic nominee Bill Thompson behind by just three points.
The “Updates
From The New York City Mayor’s Race” section contained only this. There was no
last minute fundraising push or a number for people to call and volunteer, or
anything else.
As he enters
the final hours of his uphill battle against Michael Bloomberg, Thompson has
been pulling out all the stops, circling the city and hoping to somehow cobble
together a coalition to put him in Gracie Mansion. But for a candidate looking
for all the help he can get, Thompson has not managed to get much help from
either of the political parties on whose ballot lines he will appear on
Tuesday.
The State
Democratic Party, which provided communications and infrastructure support to
past nominees, has not been out in force. Nor has the Working Families Party,
which demonstrated its unmatched effectiveness in getting voters to the polls
for its favored candidates in this year’s primaries and run-offs.
Jay Jacobs,
the new Democratic state party chair, had pledged to step up efforts for
Thompson after the primary, as had his predecessor, June O’Neill. But as is
plainly evident to outside observers and confirmed by those with inside
knowledge, those pledges have come to naught.
Jacobs did
not return calls seeking comment.
As for the
Working Families Party—though the Bloomberg campaign failed to keep Thompson
from getting its endorsement and ballot line, the mayor’s team has since
succeeded in securing or silencing most of the Party’s major forces and sources
of money: 32 BJ and the Hotel/Motel Trades Union endorsed the mayor, and both
the UFT and 1199 SEIU have sat out the race (though Bloomberg did pick up the
endorsement of national SEIU chairman Dennis Rivera). The Communications
Workers of America have released a half-million, three commercial blitz, and
the Transit Workers Union went up on the air in the closing days of the campaign
as well. But without the interest, bodies or cash to support an effort, the
Bloomberg campaign believes it has neutralized the Working Families Party as a
factor in the mayor’s race.
Plus, the
Thompson campaign is not spending any money with Data & Field Services, the
for-profit company which the Working Families Party set up to have candidates
pay for its canvassing operation.
“We have our
own extremely strong and robust field team and have not contracted out field
work through DFS,” said Thompson campaign spokesman Mike Murphy.
Still, said
WFP communications director Dan Levitan, the Party remains committed.
“WFP members and activists are online and in the streets, helping to bring Bill Thompson supporters to the polls and remind undecided voters why New York City needs change,” Levitan said, adding “all of our work will adhere to any rules governing contributions—they will be under-the-limit and we will disclose them to the campaign.”
According to
Joe Mercurio, a political consultant not affiliated with any candidate in this
year’s race, the lack of action from the Democrats and Working Families is a
function of Thompson’s trailing poll numbers and what he believes is no chance
to pull off a win.
“I don’t think it would have made any difference one way or the other, which is why they probably didn’t bother wasting resources,” Mercurio said. “It would be good money after bad for the state party and the Working Families Party.”
Mercurio
noted, though, that even if they wanted to get involved, the parties would need
to be cautious of the campaign finance laws restricting coordinated activities.
With so much attention focused especially on Data & Field Services, this
issue was of added concern, he said.
That is not good enough reason for some Thompson backers disappointed with the lack of support for their candidate.
“What just
shocks me is the silence of the Working Families Party,” said one prominent
political activist, criticizing the WFP for not being out at the same strength
for the Thompson in the general election as they were for candidates like Bill
de Blasio and John Liu during the primaries.
The lack of
help cast doubt on the WFP’s decision to endorse Thompson, the activist suggested,
claiming that it showed the Party was interested less in supporting his
candidacy than having a candidate at the top of the ticket.
“When they
went to people and asked for support for Thompson, they were not doing it
because they wanted support for Thompson—they just wanted to protect the image
of the party,” the activist said.
And in the
eyes of that activist, the state Democratic Party also had reason to be
ashamed, with consequences that might reverberate into next year’s state
elections.
“I think
that we should treat this as a failure for Paterson, because the state party
had the opportunity to show what kind of campaign it is capable of under
Paterson's leadership and it failed the test,” the activist said.
Thompson’s
campaign, meanwhile, remains optimistic.
“Democrats
from around New York City and New York State have lined up behind Bill and have
been extremely helpful in getting Bill’s message out,” said Murphy.
A lot of the
institutional manpower and energy which might have gone to Thompson seems to
instead be focused on the upstate Congressional special election, where polls
show Democratic candidate Bill Owens with a chance to flip a district which has
been in Republican hands for years. Unlike for Thompson, the state Democratic Party has sent out a fundraising email specifically for Owens and rallied behind his candidacy, and the White House, which created the vacancy
by appointing John McHugh as its army secretary, is dispatching Vice President
Joe Biden to campaign for Owens on Monday. President Barack Obama campaigned yet again with embattled New Jersey Gov. Jon Corzine on Sunday.
Asked
whether similar helped had been asked for or offered from the White House,
which many have called somewhat circumspect in its endorsement of Thompson,
Murphy said simply, “Bill is proud to have the endorsement and support of the
President Obama.”
Still, there
are those who say there should have been more.
Stuart Appelbaum,
president of the Retail Wholesale Department Store Union (RWDSU)—and a man who
has emerged as one of Thompson’s strongest and most vocal backers—said he was
disappointed not to see the state Democratic Party speaking out more about
everything from $1 million Bloomberg gave to Abyssinian Baptist Church’s
development corporation in advance of Rev. Calvin Butts’ endorsement to the
number of Bronx families living below the poverty line to the steep
unemployment numbers across the city. Those, Appelbaum said, are issues that the
forces like the Democratic and Working Families parties should be drawing
attention to, for the benefit of Thompson.
“There are principles involved,” Appelbaum said. “It’s not about personalities, it’s not about individuals. It’s about what sort of city we want this to be.”















